International Fraud Awareness Week: Patience and Coordination
Two recent cases, a staged-crash sweep in New York and an alleged adjuster scheme in Pennsylvania, show what to watch for this Fraud Awareness Week.
By Carla Rodriguez | Nov 16, 2026 | 3 min. read
What you will find below:
- Fraud’s New Playbook: Patience and Coordination
- The Inside Job
- The Takeaway
International Fraud Awareness Week usually brings to mind the classics: staged car accidents, inflated repair bills, and slip-and-falls perfectly timed in front of a security camera that just happened to be down that day. Two recent cases are a good reminder of just how organized “classic” fraud has become, and that it’s not always an outsider committing these crimes.
What they have in common is patience: both schemes were built over months, not minutes, which is exactly what makes this kind of fraud so hard to catch before the damage is done.
Fraud’s New Playbook: Patience and Coordination
On October 21, New York authorities announced the arrest of 16 people accused of staging car crashes and faking injuries to collect close to $500,000 from insurers. The cases weren’t isolated fender-benders. In the Bronx, investigators say a group deliberately sideswiped a tractor-trailer on the Cross Bronx Expressway, generating more than $154,000 in medical bills from a single staged collision. Meanwhile in Queens, a 25-year-old man allegedly staged a crash with an Amazon truck to collect more than $18,000 in no-fault benefits.
The real story here is the scale of these damages. New York insurers reported 43,811 suspected fraud incidents to the state’s Insurance Frauds Bureau in 2025 alone, and the state estimates staged crashes and related fraud add as much as $300 a year to the average driver’s insurance bill.
This wasn’t an improvised opportunistic crime. It was a coordinated task force response to rings that recruit participants, coach them on how to cause a collision, and direct them to specific clinics afterward.
The Inside Job
This recent case shows us that many times fraud doesn’t knock, it walks in. In Pennsylvania, a former claims adjuster named Glenn Allen Johnson was charged with defrauding his own employer, Donegal Insurance, out of nearly $950,000.
While working as an adjuster in 2024 and 2025, Johnson allegedly created a business called Elite Injury Representatives, LLC, made it look like a law firm representing a claimant, and used his own position to push fraudulent documentation through Donegal’s claims file, directing payment to the fake firm he controlled.
No staged crash. No fake injury. Just someone who already had legitimate access to the system, and used it to build a fraud scheme from the inside.
For a closer look at how internal access and payment controls fit together, read Insider Fraud in Insurance Claims.
The Takeaway
These cases couldn’t look more different on the surface, a street-level staged-crash ring versus a white-collar insider scheme, but both point to one crucial thing worth remembering: fraud is becoming more patient than ever. It’s made up of organized rings coaching participants through a scripted collision, someone on the inside quietly routing money to fake entities and insider knowledge being used to push fraud.
Catching one case might require looking for patterns across claims and incidents. Catching the other might require looking at who has access and how it’s being used.
Fraud Awareness Week exists because both are still happening, constantly, in every state and in every line of business. The habits that catch them (looking for patterns, verifying independently, and not assuming access equals integrity) are the same ones worth sharpening all year, not just this week.
Want help spotting patterns before they turn into losses? Connect with our team to talk through your claims investigation needs.
Sources:
- “Adjuster Created Law Firm and Fake Claim to Defraud Insurer of $1M, Officials Charge.” Claims Journal, 16 Oct. 2026, www.claimsjournal.com/news/national/2026/10/16/340753.htm.
- “New York Arrests 16 in Crackdown on Staged Insurance Crashes.” Claims Journal, 21 Oct. 2026, www.claimsjournal.com/news/national/2026/10/21/340840.htm.